Treats - The Heart of the American Cupboard
Sweets were considered a very tasty, delicacy during the 1700s. It was also considered to be a luxury since sugar was a fairly expensive item to purchase.
At PartyLike1776Again, our treats collection brings together those timeless essentials — from timely sweets like candied fruit, butters and honey. Each item carries forward the spirit of from-scratch cooking and honest ingredients, connecting today’s table to generations past.
These are more than just treats — they are a continuation of Americana itself. Simple, familiar, and made to be shared, they remind us that some of the best traditions are the ones we keep using every day.
Few things bring back memories like classic candy. From country stores and soda fountains to movie theaters and baseball games, these familiar treats have been a part of American life for generations. Whether it's a favorite from childhood or a candy you haven't seen in years, each piece carries a little bit of nostalgia.
At PartyLike1776Again, we celebrate those timeless favorites with a collection of classic American candies that have stood the test of time. From old-fashioned sweets to iconic candy bars, these treats connect generations through the simple joy of sharing something familiar.
Sometimes the sweetest part isn't the candy itself—it's the memories that come with it.
Homemade desserts have long been a part of American life, bringing families together around the table for celebrations, holidays, and everyday moments. From fruit crisps and cobblers to cakes and baked treats, these recipes have been passed down through generations and remain a cherished part of American tradition.
At PartyLike1776Again, our dessert mixes from Fowler's Mill make it easy to enjoy those classic flavors at home. Inspired by time-honored recipes and simple ingredients, these mixes help create warm, comforting desserts that pair perfectly with fruit butters, honey, and other pantry staples.
Whether you're baking for family, friends, or simply treating yourself, these desserts are a reminder that some of life's best memories are made around the kitchen table.
Long before refrigeration, families across America preserved the harvest by slowly cooking orchard fruits into rich, flavorful fruit butters. Especially cherished in Pennsylvania Dutch communities, these smooth spreads transformed apples, peaches, berries, and other fruits into a pantry staple that could be enjoyed throughout the year.
At PartyLike1776Again, our fruit butters celebrate that heritage — a true taste of Americana, rooted in tradition, crafted from simple ingredients, and enjoyed from breakfast tables to family recipes across generations.
Our caramel sauces bring rich, buttery sweetness to everyday treats and special gifts alike. They are perfect for drizzling over ice cream, stirring into coffee, pairing with apples, or adding a little extra indulgence to desserts and baked goods.
Whether included in a gift set or kept on the pantry shelf, caramel sauce is a simple way to turn something ordinary into something warm, sweet, and memorable.
Long before modern packaging, honey was often stored and sold in Muth jars, a distinctive glass jar design that dates back to the late 1800s and reflects the style of containers used by beekeepers for generations. Honey was an important part of early American life, used as a natural sweetener for tea, baking, cooking, and preserving foods long before refined sugar became common.
At PartyLike1776Again, our honey in traditional Muth jars celebrates that heritage. Filled with pure honey and packaged in a jar that feels right at home in a colonial pantry, it offers a simple connection to the flavors, traditions, and craftsmanship that have been part of American life for centuries.
For generations, a warm cup of hot chocolate has been a simple American tradition, enjoyed on cold mornings, snowy evenings, and around holiday gatherings. Rich, comforting, and easy to share, hot chocolate has long been a favorite treat for families across the country.
At PartyLike1776Again, our hot chocolate mixes from New Hope Mills continue that tradition. Made by a company that has been producing quality mixes since 1823, these classic recipes deliver the rich flavor and homemade taste that make every cup feel special.
Whether enjoyed by the fire, shared with family, or paired with your favorite baked treats, hot chocolate remains one of America's simplest and most cherished comforts.
