The Candy Counter · Made Personal
Old Fashioned Candy Gift Box
Step back up to the candy counter.
An Old Fashioned Candy Gift Box is a playful way to revisit the treats you remember choosing at the counter. Start with Penny Candy Favorites and make the assortment your own.
12 Retail Packages · Suggested Starting Mix
What’s in this candy assortment?
2 × Retail Package
Necco Wafers
One retail package (one treat).
A mixed-flavor wafer roll invites you to rediscover a familiar candy-counter ritual.
- Candy roots
- 1847
- Origin
- Massachusetts
2 × Retail Package
Charms Assorted Squares
One retail package (one treat).
Fruit-flavored hard-candy squares with a long American candy story.
- Candy roots
- 1912
- Origin
- Bloomfield
2 × Retail Package
Reed's Butterscotch Candy
One retail package (one treat).
A butterscotch hard-candy roll made for lingering over a familiar sweet flavor.
- Candy roots
- 1893
- Origin
- Chicago, Illinois
2 × Retail Package
Bonomo Turkish Taffy
One retail package (one treat).
Smack, crack and savor a chewy taffy treat with a memorable candy-counter ritual.
- Candy roots
- 1912
- Origin
- Coney Island, New York
2 × Retail Package
Slo Poke
One retail package (one treat).
Slow down and enjoy the rich chew of this old-fashioned caramel favorite.
- Candy roots
- 1926
2 × Retail Package
Fralinger's Saltwater Taffy
One retail package (one treat).
A box of saltwater taffy brings the sweet-shop spirit of the boardwalk home.
- Candy roots
- 1885
- Origin
- Atlantic City, New Jersey
Your starting mix will be selected in the builder. You can change any candy before adding the box to your cart.
Small treats with a place in your memories
This assortment is for the shopper who enjoys exploring the colorful side of the candy shelf. It makes a starting point for a nostalgic birthday gift, a family tasting, or a thank-you with personality. The list below tells you exactly which retail packages are suggested.
More about this gift
Penny Candy Favorites is the assortment name; it does not mean the candies cost a penny or arrive as loose pieces. Each selected retail package counts as one treat. You can change the mix and repeat favorites within the limits displayed in the builder.
Choosing your candy gift
Can I change the candies in this assortment?
Yes. It is a suggested starting mix. Open the builder to swap candies and adjust quantities until the required treat count is filled. Availability and per-candy limits apply.
What does the price include?
The estimated total includes the box presentation charge and the selected candies at current prices. Changes to your mix may change the total. Shipping and applicable taxes are calculated at checkout.
How are the treats counted?
One retail package counts as one treat. Check the package description for each candy; a treat is not necessarily one individual piece.
Can I add a card or check allergens?
Add an optional greeting card and personal message in the cart. Review individual product details and current manufacturer packaging for ingredients and allergens before ordering.